🦋 14. Something Rare, Something Wrong
Previously in Evangeline’s story…
Evangeline moved through another ordinary day in her office at Pembroke House — meetings, spreadsheets, and lately the heaviness of corporate life increasingly weighing her down. Then a message arrived from Alexander Moreau’s executive assistant, Claire: he would see her artwork the following Wednesday. That evening, in the hush of the attic, she stood before her paintings and chose which ones to take.
The story continues:
On the allotted Wednesday, the taxi moved slowly through Mayfair, caught in the particular mid-afternoon gridlock that London seemed to produce without effort or apology.
Evangeline sat in the back seat with six canvases wrapped in cloth and brown paper, arranged carefully beside her and across her lap. They were years of quiet, private work, and she felt a nervous twinge in her stomach at the thought of them being seen by the discerning and experienced eye of Alexander Moreau.
The address Claire had sent was on St James’s Street. Moreau Capital Partners occupied the upper floors of a Georgian building near the corner of Jermyn Street — discreet, elegant, the kind of address that announced nothing and assumed everything.
The cab pulled to a stop. She paid, gathered the paintings awkwardly, and stood on the pavement for a moment, steadying her grip.
A brass plaque beside the door. A narrow lift. And then she was rising through the building toward whatever came next.
The reception area was everything she might have expected, and yet nothing like an office.
Pale walls, high ceilings, afternoon light falling through tall windows onto polished floors. A gilt framed painting, flanked by a large ceramic pot of tall greenery on either side, hung on the far wall — something old and quiet, possibly Dutch, a still life with the particular golden glow of another century. The furniture was both simple and luxurious: a low sofa in soft grey, a pair of armchairs, a marble-topped table with a beautiful arrangement of faintly fragrant white flowers.
A young woman rose from behind a desk near the window.
“Ms Hart? I’m Claire. Mr Moreau is expecting you — please, let me help with those.”
Before Evangeline could protest, Claire had taken three of the canvases from her arms with the practised ease of someone who had been trained never to make a guest feel encumbered.
“He’s just finishing a call,” Claire said, leading her through to an adjoining room. “He won’t be a moment. Can I bring you anything? Tea, water, coffee?”
“Tea would be lovely. Thank you.”
Claire set the paintings carefully against a long table beneath the window and disappeared.
Evangeline stood alone in the room, taking it in.
It was a study more than an office — or perhaps something between the two. Bookshelves lined one wall, filled not with decorative spines but with volumes that looked read: art monographs, histories, economics, biographies. A large mahogany desk sat facing the window, its surface orderly but lived-in. On the walls hung three paintings — exquisite, clearly chosen with the same restrained confidence that seemed to mark everything in this space.
She moved closer to one of them. A woman reclining on a brocade sofa, the swirl of her skirts, made of the most exquisite fabric, surrounding her. The brushwork was extraordinary — soft and precise at once, the kind of technique that made itself seem magical.
“Singer-Sargent,” said a voice behind her. “French. Late nineteenth century. He understood light and texture better than almost anyone.”
She turned.
Alexander Moreau stood in the doorway, unhurried, his expression warm without being familiar. He wore dark suit pants, impeccably cut, a soft fine knit cashmere jumper over his shirt, no tie — elegant in the way of a man who had long since stopped thinking about elegance because it had become simply how he moved through the world.
“Ms Hart.” He crossed the room and shook her hand. “Thank you for coming. I know it’s not a small thing, carrying one’s work across London.”
“Please, call me Evie, and thank you so much for seeing me” she replied, feeling honoured he would take this time to view her work.
He gestured toward the table where her paintings waited. “Shall we?”
“Yes” she said as she breathed out, feeling her stomach begin to tighten and her heart rate quicken.
Claire returned with tea — a proper service, she noticed, not mugs — and set it on a side table before withdrawing. Alexander poured for them both, unhurried, then moved toward her canvases.
“May I?”
She nodded.
He unwrapped the first one himself, handling the brown paper with care, setting it aside before lifting the canvas and placing it on the table. Then the next, and the next, until all six stood in a row, leaning against the wall in the grey afternoon light.
He stepped back. Clasped his hands loosely. And looked.
The silence stretched.
Evangeline found herself watching his face, searching for reaction. There was none she could read — only attention. The particular quality of someone who was not glancing, not assessing for a verdict, but genuinely looking.
After what felt like a full minute, he moved closer to the first painting. A laneway in rain, the light catching wet cobblestones, a figure just-visible at the far end.
“You painted this recently?”
“A few months ago.”
He nodded slowly. “The light is very good here. Confident. You knew what you wanted.” He tilted his head. “Did you arrive at it immediately, or did you have to work toward it?”
The question surprised her. “I had to work toward it. The first version was muddier. I scraped it back and started again.”
“That was right.” He looked at her briefly. “The willingness to scrape back — that is often where the work begins. Most people cannot bear it.”
He moved to the second canvas. A kitchen interior, morning light breaking across a windowsill, the geometry of domestic stillness.
“This one holds.” he said. “The composition is stronger when you trust the negative space. You are not decorating here. You are seeing.” He pointed to the lower third. “The light is specific. It belongs to a real morning.”
She felt something loosen in her chest.
“Here, though.” He indicated the upper corner. “You lost nerve, and then you tried to correct it with more paint. It shows.” A pause. “But this is a small thing. The painting knows what it is.”
He moved through the others — a coastal landscape, a still life with winter branches, an interior with an empty chair — pausing at each, speaking only when he had something to say. His observations were precise but never harsh. He noted where the work was strong and where it faltered. He asked her questions: what she had been trying to achieve, what had resisted her, where she had felt most certain.
No one had ever spoken to her this way about her work. Not with this level of seriousness.
And then he reached the final canvas.
The portrait.
He was quiet for longer this time. Much longer.
Evangeline watched him study it — the woman turned slightly away, the mouth soft and full, the eyes expressive and guarded at once. Her cousin Eleanor. She had painted it a while ago, during a long weekend in the country, and then put it away and almost forgotten it existed.
“Tell me about this one,” Alexander said. His voice had shifted slightly — still composed, but with something more attentive beneath it.
“It’s my cousin,” Evangeline said. “I painted it years ago. I’d almost forgotten I had it, honestly.”
“And what were you trying to do?”
She considered the question. “I don’t think I was trying to do anything, exactly. I just — I wanted to paint her as she actually was. Not how she presents, but — underneath that.”
Alexander looked at the portrait again.
“You’ve succeeded,” he said quietly.
She blinked.
“I don’t know your cousin,” he continued with the graceful lilt of his French accent. “I’ve never met her. I know nothing of her life.” He turned to look at Evangeline directly. “And yet I feel I understand something true about her. There is a quality and a depth here — a kind of tenderness held in reserve. An intelligence that has learned to be careful. A beauty that is not merely physical.” He paused. “Do you see what you’ve done?”
Evangeline looked at the painting. She had always felt it was good — better, perhaps, than the others. But hearing him articulate what she had somehow captured without fully intending to, made her feel suddenly, strangely exposed.
“I didn’t plan it,” she said. “It just — came out that way.”
“That is precisely the point.” He turned back to the portrait. “The others are accomplished. Some are very good. But this one breathes differently; it sees.” A pause. “This is where your real gift lives, I suspect. Not in landscape, not in still life — though you do both well. In people. In what lies beneath the surface of a face.”
She didn’t know what to say.
He stepped back and looked at all six together. The silence was not uncomfortable — it was the silence of someone thinking carefully before speaking.
“You have an eye,” he said finally. “That much is clear. The work has consistency — a sensibility that belongs to you, not borrowed from anyone else. Some pieces are stronger than others, but that is always the case. What matters is whether there is enough genuine vision to suggest an artist, and not merely someone who has produced a few successful paintings.”
He looked at her.
“There is.”
She didn’t know what to do with the feeling that rose in her chest — something between relief and terror, as though a door had opened onto a room she had always suspected existed but never dared to enter.
“What do I do now?” she asked.
The question came out smaller than she intended.
Alexander’s expression didn’t change, but something in his regard deepened.
“I cannot give you a formula,” he said. “No one can. The path for an artist is not a ladder — it is not something you climb rung by rung with a destination clearly marked at the top.” He paused. “What I can tell you is this: you do not need more noise around the work. You do not need more workshops, more opinions, more external validation. What you need is more work. Keep painting. Not everything must be shown. Not everything must be sold. But you must keep going.”
She listened, feeling the words settle into her like stones dropping into still water.
“The question is not whether you have talent,” he said. “You have talent. The portrait alone would tell me that. The question is whether you can bear the uncertainty that comes with it — the long stretches where you cannot see the path, where no one is watching, where the work may lead nowhere.” He paused. “That is the real question. And only you can answer it.”
She was quiet for a moment.
“I don’t know if I can,” she said honestly.
“No one knows that at the beginning.” His voice was not unkind. “But you have started, you already have two pieces hanging in the Hotel Valcour. That is more than most people ever do.”
He helped her wrap the paintings again, handling them with the same care she did. At the door to his study, he paused.
“The portrait,” he said. “I hope you will do more work in that direction. You have something rare there — the ability to see beneath the surface of a face. It would be a shame not to pursue it.”
It was not advice, exactly. It was an observation, offered without pressure.
“Thank you again,” she said. “For your time. For your opinion and feedback. I truly appreciate it.”
“It was not a hardship.” A slight smile crossed his face — warm, restrained, genuine. “Good work deserves proper attention. And good work is rarer than people imagine. Keep going.”
Claire appeared and helped her with the canvases, and then she was back in the lift, descending through the building, the paintings heavy in her arms and something heavier still settling in her chest.
The taxi moved slowly through the early evening traffic, the city sliding past the window in its grey November light.
She sat with the paintings beside her and tried to organise what she was feeling.
He had seen her. He had looked at her work — really looked. He had spoken to her as though she were serious, as though her efforts deserved the weight of his attention. And he had identified something in the portrait that she herself had barely understood.
This is where your real gift lives. In people. In what lies beneath the surface of a face.
The words moved through her, rearranging something viscerally inside her.
For years she had painted in private — in the attic, in the stolen hours from the ordinary demands of life — without any real expectation that it would lead anywhere. It had been enough, she told herself, simply to do it. Simply to have that quiet, private space where she could disappear into colour and light and the slow, absorbing work of making something exist that hadn’t existed before, purely for her own pleasure.
But now, watching the city pass beyond the car window, she understood that it had never been enough. Not really. Somewhere beneath her acceptance of ‘painting-as-hobby’, beneath the sensible accommodation with corporate life and climbing its ladder, there had always been something else. A hunger she had learned long ago to keep quiet. A dream she had folded away so carefully that she had almost convinced herself it wasn’t there.
It was there.
She could feel it now — stirring, stretching, pressing against the edges of the life she had built. The long-dormant wings of something that was awakening and wanted, very badly, to fly.
And yet.
The golden handcuffs of her salary. The mortgage. The practical architecture of a life that had been constructed, brick by brick, around stability and progression and the slow accumulation of security. She thought of her office on the thirteenth floor, the brass plaque beside her door, the meetings that consumed her days in careful increments of professionally dressed tedium.
She thought of Moreau’s words: The question is whether you can bear the uncertainty.
He had given her no roadmap. No formula. No clear path forward. He had given her something harder and more valuable than that — a standard, and the implicit suggestion that she might be capable of meeting it.
But meeting it would require — what, exactly? Leaving her job? Painting full-time with no income, no clients, no guarantee that any of it would amount to anything? The thought was alarming. And yet the alternative — returning to her desk, sitting through another meeting about strategic alignment, looking at spread sheets and reports, feeling the hours lift out of her life in neat professional portions — that was terrifying too, in a different way. A slower, seemingly endless, and more chronic kind of death.
She didn’t know what to do or even where to begin, the sensation rising in her of standing on the threshold of a deep cavern you can’t see into, knowing somewhere in there is a path that leads to where you want to go, but having no idea where that path is or how to find it.
The taxi turned onto her street, the Victorian terraces rising familiar and unchanged on either side.
The house was quiet when she let herself in.
She carried the paintings upstairs and leaned them against the wall in the attic, then stood for a moment in the golden half-light, staring out over the rooftops outside the large paned window.
You have something rare there he had said.
She left the attic and went downstairs to make dinner, moving through the familiar motions of chopping, stirring, seasoning — the ordinary rhythms of domestic life that she could do with her eyes closed.
Scott came home just after seven.
“Hey.” He set his bag down, kissed her briefly on the temple. “Something smells good.”
“Chicken,” she said. “It’ll be ready in twenty minutes.”
“Perfect.” He was already moving toward the lounge, phone in hand. “Long day. Could murder a beer.”
She heard the fridge open, the hiss of a bottle cap, the television coming on. She stood at the stove and stirred the sauce and felt the distance between them like a physical thing — not hostile, not cold, just there. The accumulated weight of two people who had stopped truly seeing each other somewhere along the way.
Later, over dinner, she told him about the meeting.
“I went to see Alexander Moreau this afternoon,” she said. “I showed him the paintings.”
Scott looked up from his plate. “Oh, right. The French bloke. How’d that go?”
She opened her mouth to explain — the office on St James’s Street, the Singer-Sargent on the wall, the way Moreau had looked at her work with such careful, unhurried attention, what he had said about the portrait — but Scott’s eyes had already drifted back to his phone, which lay beside his plate, screen glowing with some notification.
“It went well,” she said. “He was very — thorough. Very serious about it.”
“That’s good.” He glanced up briefly, smiled, looked down again. “Good for you, babe.”
She watched him for a moment — the familiar face, the easy half-attention, the way he held his fork while scrolling with his other hand — and felt something small and tired fold itself away inside her.
“He said I have real talent,” she said quietly. “He said the portrait of Eleanor was exceptional.”
“Mm.” Scott nodded, still looking at his phone. “That’s great.”
She stopped talking.
He didn’t notice.
After a moment, he set the phone aside and looked up as though resuming a conversation that had been proceeding normally all along.
Listen,” he said, “I’ve got that work thing in Edinburgh this weekend. Early flight Friday. I’ll be back Saturday afternoon.
She blinked. “This weekend?” It was already Wednesday night.
“Yeah.” He reached for his beer. “I told you about it. The Calder situation — they’re being difficult about the restructure. David needs someone senior up there.”
She didn’t remember him telling her. She was almost certain he hadn’t.
“I don’t think you mentioned it,” she said carefully.
“Pretty sure I did. Last week, remember?” He shrugged, easy and certain.
She watched him cut into his chicken, untroubled, and felt the small cold current move beneath her attention again.
“Who’s going with you?” she asked lightly.
He paused. Just slightly. Just enough.
“What do you mean?”
“To Edinburgh. Are you going alone, or is the team —”
“It’s a client meeting, Evie.” There was an edge in his voice now — faint but unmistakable. “I’ll be in sessions all day. It’s not a holiday.”
“I wasn’t saying —”
“I know.” He softened, but not all the way. “I’m just knackered. Long week.” He said it in a way that dismissed the subject entirely.
She nodded and said nothing more.
He finished eating, took his plate to the sink, mentioned something about a late match he wanted to catch. She heard him settle into the lounge, the television volume rising, and she sat alone at the table looking at the remains of dinner and trying to understand why her chest felt tight in a way that had nothing to do with the meal.
I told you about it, didn’t I?
But he hadn’t. She knew he hadn’t.
And the way he’d hesitated when she asked who was going with him. The slight edge of irritation, as though the question itself were unreasonable. The way he hadn’t actually answered it.
She stood and began clearing the table, moving through the motions, telling herself she was being ridiculous. It was a work trip. There was nothing unusual about a work trip. People travelled for work all the time. Scott travelled for work regularly. This was not new.
And yet.
Something didn’t sit right. Something in the way he had presented it — made her feel, for a moment, as though she were standing on ground that had shifted slightly beneath her feet.
She dried her hands on the tea towel and stood at the kitchen window, looking out at the dark garden.
The conversation with Moreau felt very far away now. The portrait, the praise, the carefully offered words about her talent — all of it had receded, overlaid by this new, uncomfortable feeling that she couldn’t quite name.
She was being paranoid. She was tired. She was overthinking.
I told you about it.
She tried to let it go.
But later that night, lying in the dark beside Scott’s sleeping form, she found she couldn’t.
She lay very still, staring at the ceiling.
The house was quiet around her. The faint sound of a car passing outside. The distant bark of a fox somewhere in the dark.
She thought about the afternoon —and having no idea exactly how to proceed from here.
And beneath all of that, quieter but persistent, the trip to Edinburgh kept playing at the front of her mind.
Who’s going with you?
He had deflected, grown irritated, made her feel as though asking were somehow unreasonable.
But somewhere beneath her thoughts, in a place deeper than logic or reason, a subtle certainty about him seemed to settle into her bones. Her mind circled questions she was not yet brave enough to ask.
📖 Missed the previous instalment? → click here
📘 Ready for the next instalment? → click here